Skip to main content

Film review · 2014

No Hope For Men Below

No Hope For Men Below

***1/2

Reviewed by: Andrew Robertson

The Redding Pit flooded in 1923, trapping fathers and sons while their women waited above. Based on a poem by Janet Paisley, this is a haunting mixture of re-enactment and re-construction. Written in broad Scots, subtitled but not directly translated, this is an emotional piece of documentary.

Made possible in part by Kickstarter, this is a striking work - the stark white of bread in paper, the shine of a piece-tin, a score by the One Ensemble Orchestra, baleful eyes shining in the implacable dark, and the endless drip of water. Mournful, literally elegaic, this is an affecting piece, and worth seeking out.

Reviewed on: 17 Feb 2014

Source JustWatch

If you like this, try:

The Happy Lands
Review preview for The Happy Lands

The Happy Lands would work better on television but it is still, in many ways, a strong piece of work.

Jennie Kermode · 2.5 out of 5